The Widening Divide Between Celtic and Rangers: A Season of Contrasts and Challenges
The rivalry between Celtic and Rangers, known as the Old Firm, is arguably one of the fiercest and most historic in world football. For decades, these two Glasgow giants have battled not just for trophies but for supremacy in Scottish football, cultural pride, and dominance on and off the pitch. Yet, as the 2025 season unfolds, the chasm between the two clubs has arguably never been wider, a divide that is deeply felt both in their performances on the pitch and in the wider structures that support their ambitions.
Rangers’ Struggles: A Season Mired in Inconsistency and Frustration
Rangers, once the dominant force alongside Celtic in Scotland, are finding themselves in unfamiliar territory. The team’s current position—scrambling to maintain a place in the Premiership’s top six—is a stark contrast to the expectations that have surrounded them in recent years. From the outside, it appears Rangers have lost their way, struggling to find consistency in their performances week after week.
The Europa League defeat to Genk was emblematic of their troubles. A narrow 1-0 loss on the European stage underlined their defensive frailties and lack of cutting edge in attack. For a club with European ambitions, such results bring to light deeper systemic issues. The inability to assert themselves domestically only exacerbates the pressure on manager Russell Martin and the squad. Fans and pundits alike have expressed growing frustration, with many questioning whether the current leadership can navigate the pressures and complexities of managing Rangers in a demanding league.
Derek Ferguson’s candid remarks reflect a broader sentiment of disappointment. As someone who knows the club’s traditions and the high standards expected, Ferguson did not mince words. He highlighted that Rangers have a manager who understands the league but is failing to translate that understanding into results. Ferguson pointed out that Rangers fans expect exciting, high-energy, attacking football—a style that Rangers have historically prided themselves on. Instead, they have witnessed a side that lacks intensity and fails to inspire. This mismatch between expectation and reality has created a palpable tension around the club.
BBC presenter Kenny McIntyre added fuel to the fire by suggesting that Rangers are “miles off Celtic” at present. His assessment extends beyond just results, implying a significant gap in squad quality and overall team cohesion. What’s more telling is his comparison to Hearts, who are currently above Rangers in the table and have been playing with a cohesion and determination that Rangers seem to lack. This comparison is shocking for many, given Rangers’ resources and stature, and serves as a stark warning sign.
Celtic’s Continued Dominance and Strategic Stability
In sharp contrast, Celtic continue to project an image of stability and dominance under Brendan Rodgers. Despite a recent draw against Hibernian that cost them valuable points at Parkhead, Celtic’s overall form remains solid. Rodgers’ management style—marked by tactical flexibility, meticulous preparation, and a calm yet demanding presence—has given Celtic a consistent edge in the league.
Celtic’s squad, blending experienced leaders with promising young talent, appears well-equipped to maintain their winning ways. The team’s ability to control games, limit defensive lapses, and create scoring opportunities has been evident throughout the season. While Rangers are struggling to find rhythm, Celtic have demonstrated resilience and focus, crucial qualities for a side chasing a historic fifth consecutive league title.
The previous Old Firm meeting at Ibrox, which ended in a goalless draw, showcased Celtic’s tactical discipline and ability to neutralize Rangers’ threats. Though the fixture lacked goals, it underscored the gulf in quality and preparation. Rodgers’ Celtic are methodical and confident, qualities that have made them the team to beat in Scottish football.
Managerial Challenges: Rodgers vs. Martin
The contrast between Brendan Rodgers and Russell Martin couldn’t be starker. Rodgers, with his wealth of managerial experience across top leagues in England and abroad, has a clear blueprint for success. He knows how to build winning teams and manage the pressures that come with leading a club like Celtic. His approach combines tactical intelligence with man-management skills that keep players motivated and focused.
Russell Martin, despite his background with Rangers as a player, is still finding his feet in management at this level. While he understands the club’s culture and expectations, his ability to inspire and deliver consistent results has been questioned. The criticism from figures like Derek Ferguson suggests that Martin’s tactical approach and leadership style have not resonated with the squad or supporters. This puts Rangers in a difficult position: should the club back Martin to build long-term success, or is a managerial change inevitable if performances don’t improve?
Squad Quality and Depth: A Tale of Two Clubs
Squad depth and quality are key factors in any title race or club’s competitiveness in multiple competitions. Celtic’s recruitment and player development have been noteworthy. The team boasts a balanced mix of seasoned internationals and exciting youngsters, providing Rodgers with tactical options and the ability to manage fatigue and injuries effectively.
Rangers, on the other hand, appear to be lacking in both quality and cohesion. Injuries, inconsistent performances, and perhaps some questionable recruitment decisions have left the squad thin in key areas. The inability to perform both domestically and in Europe points to deeper structural issues that need addressing if Rangers are to close the gap.
The Road Ahead: Crucial Fixtures and What They Mean
The coming months will be decisive for both clubs. Celtic face Hearts at Tynecastle on October 26th—a match that promises to be intense given Hearts’ strong form and position in the league. A victory there would solidify Celtic’s position at the top and send a strong message to their rivals. For Hearts, it’s a chance to prove they belong among the elite this season.
Rangers will get their chance to respond at Celtic Park on January 3rd in what will be a high-pressure Old Firm derby. If Russell Martin remains in charge, this fixture could be a defining moment for his tenure. A poor showing could deepen the crisis at Ibrox, while a strong performance might buy him more time and restore some confidence.
Historical Context and Future Implications
The Old Firm rivalry has always been about more than just football—social, cultural, and economic factors intertwine with on-pitch results. The current imbalance threatens to alter the traditional narrative that has fueled Scottish football for over a century. Celtic’s sustained dominance could lead to a period of stagnation in competitiveness unless Rangers or other clubs rise to challenge them effectively.
For Rangers, this season could be a turning point. The club needs to reassess its strategies—both managerial and operational—to reclaim its status. Whether this means investing more in player recruitment, restructuring the coaching staff, or redefining club ambitions remains to be seen.
For Celtic, maintaining focus and avoiding complacency will be crucial. Winning five league titles in a row is a monumental achievement, but history shows that prolonged dominance is often followed by challenges as rivals regroup.
Conclusion
The gulf between Celtic and Rangers in the 2025 season is a complex, multi-layered issue that extends beyond the scoreboard. Celtic’s stability, tactical acumen, and squad depth position them well to continue their reign, while Rangers face significant challenges both on and off the field. The coming months and key fixtures will provide clarity on whether Rangers can rise to the occasion or if Celtic’s dominance will continue unabated.
This season is shaping up to be a defining chapter in Scottish football’s rich history—one that could reshape the Old Firm rivalry for years to come.