Nottingham Forest’s Date with Destiny: The FA Cup Semi-Final, VAR Controversy, and the Hope for Fair Play at Wembley
Nottingham Forest stand on the brink of history. For the first time in over three decades, they are just 90 minutes away from reaching an FA Cup final. But even before a ball has been kicked at Wembley, controversy hangs in the air, and for those who’ve followed Forest’s journey closely in recent years, it’s a sadly familiar cloud.
As the final preparations are made for their semi-final clash against the might of Manchester City, many Forest supporters find their excitement tempered by a deep-rooted concern—will the game be decided on the pitch, or in the VAR booth? In a season that has already seen the East Midlands club locked in an ongoing struggle with the Premier League’s officiating body, the latest refereeing appointments have added fuel to a fire that has never really gone out.
A Season Marred by Controversy
Last season, Forest’s relationship with match officials hit an all-time low. A series of questionable decisions—many of them critical to results—built a narrative of injustice that became impossible to ignore. It all came to a head in April 2024 at Goodison Park, where Forest, scrapping for points in a relegation battle, were inexplicably denied three penalties in one game against Everton. Each incident seemed clearer than the last, and yet no spot-kick was given. VAR, led by Stuart Attwell—who was widely believed to have links to Luton Town, a direct relegation rival—failed to intervene.
The fallout was seismic. Forest’s Greek billionaire owner, Evangelos Marinakis, took to social media in a furious outburst aimed squarely at the officials. The FA responded, not by examining the decisions, but by slapping Marinakis with a staggering £750,000 fine—one of the largest in English football history for misconduct related to officiating comments. That punishment only deepened the perception among Forest supporters that their club wasn’t just battling 11 men on the pitch each week, but an institutional bias from those meant to oversee the game with impartiality.
To try and address the issue, Forest brought in former top-flight referee Mark Clattenburg as a referee consultant—an unprecedented move that showed just how seriously the club was taking the matter. Yet, if the intention was to build bridges and foster better communication with the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Limited), it hasn’t borne much fruit. This season has still seen decisions go against Forest in crucial moments, and frustrations continue to simmer.
The Road to Wembley
Despite all the turmoil, Forest have fought their way through to the semi-finals of the world’s oldest football competition. The FA Cup is more than just a trophy—it’s a symbol of tradition, of magic, of glory for clubs who dream beyond the confines of the league table. Forest’s journey to this point has been hard-earned, with gritty wins and inspired moments along the way. They’ve been driven by belief, by history, and by a fanbase that has stuck by them through thick and thin.
Now, the chance to return to an FA Cup final for the first time since 1991 is just one step away. On Sunday, over 30,000 Forest supporters will descend upon Wembley, their voices ready to echo through the rafters of England’s national stadium. For many, it will be their first time seeing Forest in such a monumental match. For older fans, it’s a reminder of what this club used to be—a European powerhouse, a name that once struck fear into the biggest clubs on the continent.
And yet, as the anticipation builds, so too does a familiar anxiety.
The Match Officials
Michael Oliver has been appointed as the referee for Sunday’s match. Widely regarded as the most accomplished English referee currently operating, Oliver has officiated Champions League knockouts and Premier League title deciders. His experience and temperament make him, on paper, the safest pair of hands for such an occasion. However, even he has not been immune to scrutiny this season. A few questionable performances and a perceived dip in consistency have left some wondering whether the pressures of elite-level officiating are catching up with even the most respected names.
But the real controversy lies with the choice of VAR—Andy Madley. For the second consecutive FA Cup match involving Forest, Madley will be on VAR duty. In the previous round, it was Madley who advised referee Peter Bankes to overturn a penalty awarded to Forest for a foul on Elliot Anderson. The decision left fans incensed, not only because of the nature of the call, but because it was yet another in a long line of crucial moments that didn’t fall their way. The optics of Madley once again being in charge of VAR have not gone down well with supporters who feel their club is being unfairly targeted or, at best, poorly treated.
In an era where trust in officiating is already eroding, especially with the inconsistency of VAR decisions across competitions, the appointment feels like a needless provocation. Why risk further controversy when other officials could have been chosen? Why expose the game to the risk of being overshadowed by yet another VAR headline?
Facing the Champions
Of course, the challenge on the pitch is daunting. Manchester City are the reigning FA Cup holders and a juggernaut in every sense of the word. Pep Guardiola’s side have made Wembley a second home, with their technical superiority and ruthless mentality making them one of the most formidable sides in Europe. They will be expected to dominate possession, dictate tempo, and suffocate any opposition into submission.
But cup football isn’t always logical. It doesn’t always bow to the favourites. It thrives on chaos, on moments, on belief. And Forest have belief in abundance.
Whether it’s the resurgence of Morgan Gibbs-White, the tenacity of Ryan Yates, or the resilience of a back line that has been patched together but continues to fight, Forest are not heading to London just to make up the numbers. They are going there with intent. With purpose. With the dream of a new story to tell their children and grandchildren.
Let Football Be the Winner
In the end, that’s all anyone truly wants. That when the final whistle blows on Sunday, the headlines are about the football. About a moment of magic, a last-minute winner, or a brave underdog performance—not about a questionable penalty call or a VAR decision that takes five minutes and drains the soul from the game.
Forest have waited over 30 years for a day like this. They’ve been through the pain of relegation, the chaos of ownership changes, and the slow climb back to relevance. They’ve earned their place at Wembley.
And while Manchester City will start as favourites, football isn’t played on paper. It’s played on grass, under floodlights, in front of tens of thousands of passionate fans. It’s in those moments—between doubt and glory—that legends are born.
Nottingham Forest are ready. Now, all they ask is a fair game.
Let me know if you’d like a version formatted as a blog post, newsletter piece, or for a club forum—it’s easy to tweak depending on your audience.