Jamie Carragher Admits Massive Blunder Over Virgil van Dijk — “I Completely Misjudged Him at Celtic!”

April 25, 2025

Virgil van Dijk: The Making of a Modern Defensive Giant – From Celtic to World Class

Virgil van Dijk’s journey from a promising Dutch defender to one of the most dominant central defenders of his generation is a testament to talent, timing, and the importance of the right development environment. While the football world now regards him as a colossus of the game—Champions League winner, Premier League champion, Ballon d’Or runner-up—it’s worth remembering that his rise to the top didn’t begin in the Premier League or on the international stage. It began in Glasgow, at Celtic Football Club.

Van Dijk arrived at Celtic in June 2013 as something of an unknown to most fans outside the Netherlands. Signed from FC Groningen for around £2.6 million, the Dutchman had impressed in the Eredivisie with his composure on the ball and physical presence. Still, it was seen by some as a bit of a gamble—after all, Scottish football, for all its passionate following, is not always considered a top breeding ground for global superstars.

But anyone who watched him at Celtic Park could see there was something different about this defender. Tall and imposing, yes—but also graceful. Van Dijk didn’t just win headers and put in crunching tackles; he passed with elegance, carried the ball into midfield with confidence, and read the game like someone with ten years more experience. It didn’t take long for him to make his mark in Scottish football.

Over the course of two seasons at Celtic, van Dijk made 115 appearances and scored 15 goals—a remarkable tally for a centre-back. He won two Scottish Premiership titles and a Scottish League Cup, anchoring the defence as Celtic dominated domestically. But it wasn’t just the trophies or the clean sheets that stood out—it was how effortlessly he seemed to control games. He strolled through matches, barely breaking a sweat, gliding across the pitch with an aura of complete calm.

And yet, despite his dominance in Scotland, English clubs remained hesitant. Former Liverpool defender and Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher recently reflected on this strange reluctance to move for van Dijk during his Celtic days. Speaking on the Stick to Football podcast, Carragher admitted he got his first impression of van Dijk all wrong.

“I remember going to a game, Celtic v Ajax in the Champions League in 2013/14,” Carragher said. “I didn’t really know too much about van Dijk. And I think Steve Bruce might have been manager of Hull or someone near them. And there were a few people watching van Dijk, and I watched him in the game. I’m not going to sit here and say, ‘Oh, they should have signed him.’ He almost looked too big, at that time. Do you know what I mean?”

Carragher went on to explain how van Dijk’s style might have worked against him in the eyes of scouts. “He almost played that cool, that sort of slow motion. And teams were watching him, and obviously just didn’t want to take a chance.”

That notion—that van Dijk was too composed, too smooth in his movements—is fascinating. His relaxed style, which is now seen as one of his greatest strengths, may have once been misread as a lack of intensity or dynamism. But what Carragher and others saw as “slow motion” was, in reality, anticipation, timing, and control. It was the kind of poise that only the very best defenders possess.

Eventually, one club did take that chance. In 2015, Southampton signed van Dijk for £11.5 million—making him one of Celtic’s most expensive ever sales. For the Scottish champions, it was another success story in their growing reputation for identifying and developing hidden gems. For van Dijk, it was the beginning of the next phase of his career.

Interestingly, it was only after his move to the Premier League that van Dijk broke into the Netherlands national team. Despite being arguably the best defender in Scottish football for two years, he didn’t earn a senior cap until October 2015, just weeks after his move to Southampton. It’s a telling sign of how the wider football world sometimes undervalues talent in the Scottish league. Yet those who watched him week in and week out at Celtic knew this was no ordinary centre-back.

At Southampton, van Dijk quickly proved the doubters wrong. His performances in the Premier League were outstanding, and he soon caught the attention of the top clubs. In January 2018, Liverpool came calling, paying a world-record £75 million fee for a defender—a figure that raised eyebrows at the time but now looks like a bargain. Since arriving at Anfield, van Dijk has been nothing short of phenomenal.

He transformed Liverpool’s back line almost overnight, bringing leadership, aerial dominance, composure, and impeccable positioning. Under Jurgen Klopp, he became the rock on which Liverpool’s modern success was built. In 2019, he helped Liverpool win the UEFA Champions League, followed by the UEFA Super Cup and FIFA Club World Cup. In 2020, he played a crucial role in the club’s first league title in 30 years. His individual accolades included the PFA Players’ Player of the Year and the UEFA Men’s Player of the Year, and he finished second in the 2019 Ballon d’Or voting—an extraordinary achievement for a defender in the modern era.

Now 33, van Dijk remains a vital figure at Liverpool. He recently signed a new deal with the club, affirming his commitment to Klopp’s long-term project. With over 80 caps for the Netherlands and a growing legacy as one of the game’s all-time great centre-backs, his career is a beacon of what is possible with the right blend of talent, opportunity, and development.

For Celtic fans, van Dijk’s story is one of immense pride. Here was a player who came to Glasgow as a talented but largely unknown Dutch defender and left as a star-in-the-making. Celtic gave him the stage, the minutes, and the pressure of European nights. It was in the green and white hoops that he developed the confidence and composure that would define his career.

Jamie Carragher may have doubted him at first, but he—like the rest of the football world—now fully appreciates what van Dijk brings. That Carragher openly admitted he got it wrong is not only a credit to his honesty, but also a reflection of how far van Dijk has come.

And for all the trophies, individual awards, and iconic moments he’s had since leaving Celtic, many fans still remember where the world first started to notice the Dutch defender who played like a Rolls-Royce in the heart of defence.

At Celtic Park, where legends are born and celebrated, Virgil van Dijk’s name will always carry a special kind of respect—not just for what he achieved there, but for everything he became afterwards.


Would you like this turned into a visual article or graphic timeline as well?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *