Ethan Ampadu’s performance in Leeds United’s 3-0 Yorkshire derby victory over Sheffield Wednesday has been overshadowed by controversy, with former Premier League and FIFA referee Keith Hackett accusing the Wales international of “cheating” during the match.
The incident occurred in the second half when Wednesday midfielder Shea Charles was penalized for a robust challenge on Ampadu. While Charles did approach the challenge with noticeable aggression, there appeared to be no contact with Ampadu’s legs. Nevertheless, Ampadu went down clutching his shin, as though he had been struck, which led to significant backlash from both Sheffield Wednesday supporters and neutral observers. Hackett, who is also a Sheffield Wednesday fan, took aim at Ampadu’s actions, labeling them as an example of unsportsmanlike behavior in the modern game.
Hackett expressed his frustration in comments to MOT Leeds News, stating: “There is no doubt that the feigning of injury from robust challenges is a plague in the modern game. In my era, these took place and were part of the game. You would get players holding out an arm and helping the opponent up off the ground. There was less cheating and more physicality years ago; Norman Hunter, Billy Bremner, and Vinnie Jones come to mind.”
Hackett’s remarks highlight the ongoing debate about the increasing prevalence of simulation in football. Many purists argue that players are now more inclined to exaggerate contact or even feign injury in an attempt to sway referees, something that was less common during previous eras of the sport. Hackett contrasted Ampadu’s actions with the gritty, hard-nosed approach of Leeds legends like Hunter and Bremner, suggesting they would be “ashamed” of such behavior.
Despite the controversy, Ampadu has been one of Leeds United’s most reliable performers this season. The 24-year-old has made 16 appearances across all competitions and played a pivotal role in Daniel Farke’s midfield. His ability to control games and protect the backline has been crucial to Leeds’ success, and his leadership qualities have been evident throughout the campaign. Ampadu’s presence in the Yorkshire derby was no different, as Leeds dominated Sheffield Wednesday with goals from Manor Solomon, Largie Ramazani, and Ao Tanaka securing the comfortable win.
The victory propelled Leeds back to the top of the Championship table, overtaking Sheffield United with a one-point lead after 27 matches. However, incidents like the one involving Ampadu and Charles cast a shadow over an otherwise commanding display. Critics argue that Ampadu’s actions detract from the credibility of the team’s performance and highlight a broader issue in modern football.
While opinions on the incident may differ, the debate underscores the challenges referees face in discerning genuine fouls from simulated ones. Players like Ampadu, who are highly competitive and integral to their teams, often find themselves at the center of such discussions. Leeds United will be hoping that the midfielder can focus on his football and continue to be a key figure in their push for promotion, leaving controversies like this behind.
As the Championship season progresses, both Ampadu and Leeds will face increased scrutiny, not only for their results but also for the manner in which they achieve them. The modern game, with its emphasis on sportsmanship and fair play, will demand a response from players like Ampadu to ensure that their actions reflect the high standards expected on the pitch.