Nottingham Forest and Match Officials: A Fractured Relationship and a Crucial Turning Point in the Relegation Run-In
Since their long-awaited return to the Premier League in 2022, Nottingham Forest’s turbulent relationship with match officials has become one of the defining narratives of their top-flight journey. While much of the focus has understandably been on performances, signings, and survival, there has been a simmering backdrop of discontent between Forest and the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Limited) that has at times overshadowed the football itself.
Now, with just five games left in the 2024/25 campaign, Forest once again find themselves in a high-pressure battle near the bottom of the table. And despite efforts to move beyond past conflicts, the specter of refereeing controversy has re-emerged — this time, in the build-up to a crucial fixture against Brentford.
But this story runs far deeper than a single match. It reflects years of frustration, accusations of bias, attempts at reform, and a fanbase that feels its club has too often been the victim of inconsistency and injustice.
From Promotion to Provocation: How Forest’s Referee Problems Began
When Nottingham Forest sealed promotion back to the Premier League after 23 years in the wilderness, there was a sense of optimism and resurgence surrounding the club. But that fairy-tale return quickly turned gritty. The Premier League is unforgiving — and not just in terms of the quality of opposition. The spotlight is intense, VAR is omnipresent, and every decision is scrutinized, especially by clubs fighting for survival.
Forest, under the ownership of Evangelos Marinakis and a passionate fanbase, have never been shy about voicing concerns. As the 2022/23 season progressed, a series of controversial refereeing calls began to stack up. Missed penalties, questionable red cards, VAR inconsistencies — each week seemed to bring a new grievance.
The breaking point came in April 2023, during a now-infamous game against Everton at Goodison Park. In a match with huge implications at the bottom of the table, Forest were denied what many deemed to be three stonewall penalties. VAR, led that day by Stuart Attwell, failed to intervene. The club’s frustration boiled over into the public domain, with officials making statements, and behind-the-scenes fury spilling into media outlets.
The fallout was immense. The FA imposed a £750,000 fine on Forest for their comments and conduct — one of the heaviest punishments ever handed down to a Premier League club for referee criticism. The message was clear: there would be no tolerance for undermining officiating authority, even when VAR appeared to fail in its core responsibilities.
2023/24: The Year of Chaos and Confrontation
Rather than resolving tensions, the 2023/24 season saw them intensify. Forest continued to feel that major decisions were going against them, and Marinakis became increasingly vocal, both privately and in statements. On more than one occasion, Forest used their official club channels to question refereeing decisions — a rare move in the typically guarded world of Premier League PR.
The relationship with the PGMOL became icy. Referee appointments to Forest games were met with skepticism, and certain officials — most notably Attwell and Paul Tierney — became focal points for fan and club frustration. At times, the discourse spiraled into farce, with some pundits accusing Forest of developing a “victim complex,” while others sympathized with what they saw as legitimate grievances.
To compound matters, the standard of officiating across the league was widely criticized. Even top clubs such as Arsenal, Liverpool, and Manchester United voiced concerns about VAR and inconsistent decision-making. But for Forest, these errors were not just frustrating — they were potentially fatal in the context of relegation.
A New Season, A New Approach?
Fast forward to the 2024/25 campaign, and a subtle shift appears to have taken place. While the refereeing grievances haven’t vanished entirely, Forest’s leadership seems to have decided that constant confrontation was not yielding results. The club dialed down public criticism, perhaps realizing that ongoing conflict with the PGMOL could lead to further sanctions or even reputational damage.
Instead, the focus was placed more squarely on the football. On the pitch, Forest looked more composed and unified. Off the pitch, the narrative of “referee victimhood” took a backseat — or at least, until the build-up to the Brentford fixture.
The Brentford Build-Up: The Attwell Flashpoint Reignites
With five games to go, Forest’s away trip to Brentford is crucial — a true six-pointer in the relegation battle. However, as the officials for the match were announced, a name reappeared that instantly triggered unease among Forest supporters: Stuart Attwell had been appointed as the VAR for the fixture.
For many fans, it was hard to believe. The same official who oversaw the Everton disaster, who was at the center of one of the club’s darkest Premier League moments, was now being given oversight of another season-defining match.
The appointment was viewed by some as provocative, or at least tone-deaf from the PGMOL. Was this a sign of indifference, or a deliberate test of Forest’s new restraint? In any case, the backlash was immediate. While the club itself didn’t issue a public statement, pressure behind the scenes seems to have had an effect.
Just hours later, Attwell was quietly replaced by Craig Pawson — a referee with a less contentious history with the club. The change was not officially explained, but its timing suggests it was made to avoid controversy and maintain the integrity of the match. For Forest fans, the switch was both a relief and a small victory — perhaps a sign that someone was finally listening.
Darren England: A Glimmer of Hope
In another stroke of relative fortune, Darren England was appointed as the on-field referee for the Brentford game. England’s last Forest assignment came in a memorable 3-2 win over Manchester United at Old Trafford. That game passed without incident, with Forest praised for their performance and England for his calm and fair officiating.
While no referee is universally trusted, England’s recent track record with Forest gives some hope that the game can be played without the drama and distraction that have so often defined their Premier League outings.
What Comes Next: The Importance of Composure
With just five games left to play, Forest must walk a tightrope. The relegation battle is fierce, with multiple clubs fighting for survival. Every decision — every foul, every card, every VAR call — could be decisive. In this environment, emotional discipline is as important as tactical execution.
Forest’s task is twofold:
- Maintain internal composure: Players, coaching staff, and leadership must avoid allowing refereeing decisions — fair or unfair — to derail their focus. The psychological impact of believing the system is against you can become corrosive.
- Hold the PGMOL accountable — constructively: While it’s important to avoid public meltdowns, it is equally essential that Forest continue to engage with officiating authorities in good faith. Constructive feedback, formal complaints where necessary, and ongoing dialogue will be more effective than angry statements or social media campaigns.
Conclusion: A Club at a Crossroads
Nottingham Forest’s ongoing saga with match officials is more than a collection of poor decisions. It speaks to the wider challenges of being a club fighting for survival in the Premier League, where the stakes are higher, the scrutiny more intense, and the margins thinner than ever.
The Brentford match and the reversal of the Attwell appointment may represent a small but significant turning point. If Forest can maintain their current approach — focusing on performance while calmly managing the officiating narrative — they may yet write a successful ending to a season filled with tension and turmoil.
The next five games will test more than just their footballing credentials. They will test Forest’s maturity, composure, and unity — qualities just as vital as goals and clean sheets in a battle for Premier League survival.
Would you like a fixture-by-fixture breakdown of Forest’s remaining games and relegation odds?