Edson Álvarez’s struggles at West Ham United have come under intense scrutiny, with Perry Groves’ scathing criticism during the Hammers’ clash against Manchester City epitomizing the growing concerns surrounding the Mexican midfielder’s performances this season. Speaking on talkSPORT 2, Groves singled out Álvarez for what he described as “shocking defending,” accusing him of ducking out of a crucial aerial challenge that ultimately led to Manchester City’s opening goal. Groves’ damning remarks, calling Álvarez a player you “wouldn’t want in the trenches,” reflect a growing sentiment of frustration among fans and pundits over his inability to deliver in key moments.

Since his arrival from Ajax in the summer of 2023, Álvarez has struggled to adapt to the physical and relentless nature of the Premier League. While his technical qualities and ability to dictate the tempo of a game are evident, his performances have been marred by inconsistency, lapses in judgment, and disciplinary issues. His two red cards this season are symptomatic of a player who has been unable to find the balance between aggression and composure, leaving West Ham exposed in critical situations.

Julen Lopetegui, who took over as manager at the London Stadium, has shown signs of losing faith in Álvarez. The midfielder’s struggles were highlighted during West Ham’s recent 5-0 loss to Liverpool, where he was hauled off at halftime, and in the previous game against Southampton, where he started on the bench. These decisions suggest that Lopetegui is running out of patience with Álvarez’s inability to step up in crucial moments, particularly as the team’s form has wavered and his own position has come under increasing pressure.

West Ham’s defensive frailties have been a recurring issue this season, and Álvarez’s inability to offer solidity in the middle of the park has been a significant factor. Against Manchester City, his decision to turn his back and avoid the aerial challenge directly contributed to the opposition’s goal, as Groves pointed out in his commentary. Such moments not only undermine the team’s defensive structure but also sap confidence from his teammates and fans. For a player brought in to add steel and stability to West Ham’s midfield, these errors are unacceptable, especially when the manager’s job hangs in the balance.

It’s worth noting that Álvarez played 42 games in all competitions under David Moyes last season, showcasing his durability and ability to perform in high-pressure situations. However, this season’s performances have failed to reach those levels, leaving many to question whether he can truly thrive in the Premier League’s demanding environment. His struggles mirror those of his teammates, with the Hammers enduring an inconsistent campaign that has left them languishing in the bottom half of the table.

What West Ham needs right now is leadership and resilience, qualities that Álvarez has yet to consistently demonstrate. In moments like the one against Manchester City, fans and pundits expect a player of his caliber and experience to rise to the occasion, showing bravery and determination. Instead, his decision to duck out of a challenge has only fueled criticism and raised questions about his commitment and mentality.

For Lopetegui, the stakes could not be higher. With his job reportedly on the line, he cannot afford to field players who are unable or unwilling to engage in the physical battles that define Premier League matches. Álvarez’s technical skills are undeniable, but unless he can combine them with the grit and determination required to succeed in England, his place in the starting XI will remain under threat.

The Mexican international, capped 83 times for his country, must now prove that he can turn things around. He has the ability to dictate games and make a positive impact, but time is running out for him to show consistency and reliability. West Ham’s season, and potentially Lopetegui’s tenure, could hinge on players like Álvarez stepping up and delivering when it matters most. If he fails to do so, both his and Lopetegui’s futures at the club could be in serious jeopardy.