Lucas Paquetá’s future has long been a subject of speculation, and Jamie Carragher’s recent comments highlight an important aspect of why certain top clubs, such as Liverpool, might hesitate to move for him. Speaking on The Overlap’s Fan Debate (3 February), Carragher praised the Brazilian’s skill and technical quality, describing him as a “bit of a throwback” after his performance against Aston Villa. However, he also questioned whether Paquetá’s lack of athleticism would make him a poor fit for a highly structured and physically demanding system like Arne Slot’s at Liverpool.
The Athleticism Debate: Where Does Paquetá Fit?
Carragher’s assessment touches on a key issue that separates Paquetá from the archetypal modern midfielder in the Premier League. His elegant, languid style makes him a joy to watch, but it can also raise concerns in a league where intensity, pressing, and work rate are paramount. Liverpool, under both Jürgen Klopp and now Arne Slot, have thrived on high-energy midfielders who can cover ground quickly, make recovery runs, and contribute to aggressive pressing schemes. Players like Dominik Szoboszlai, Alexis Mac Allister, and Ryan Gravenberch have all been recruited with this physical profile in mind.
Paquetá, by contrast, is a more deliberate, technically refined player who excels in tight spaces and in dictating play rather than relentlessly covering ground. While he is undoubtedly gifted, this stylistic difference could make him a difficult fit for Liverpool or any other elite side that prioritizes relentless off-the-ball work. That isn’t to say he lacks work ethic—he does contribute defensively—but his mobility is not at the level of Liverpool’s preferred midfielders.
Transfer Speculation and the Manchester City Saga
Despite these concerns, Paquetá remains a highly valued player, as evidenced by Manchester City’s long-standing interest in him. The Premier League champions were keen on securing his services, and a transfer seemed to be in the works before his FA betting charges came to light. The allegations halted any immediate prospects of a big-money move, leaving Paquetá in limbo. If he is cleared, City—or another top club—could reignite their interest, particularly given his ability to operate as a deep-lying playmaker or in an advanced role.
Pep Guardiola’s system, which relies on ball retention and positional play rather than pure athleticism, might be a better fit for Paquetá than Liverpool’s approach. City’s use of technically gifted midfielders like Kevin De Bruyne and Bernardo Silva suggests there could still be a place for a player of his profile. However, given the unpredictability surrounding his betting case, any potential move remains uncertain.
A Frustrating but Talented Enigma at West Ham
At West Ham, Paquetá has had moments of brilliance but has also frustrated fans at times. His skill is unquestionable, but when the team is struggling or under pressure, his style can appear passive rather than proactive. This is a common criticism of creative midfielders who prefer to play at their own tempo rather than adapting to a frantic game.
His performances this season have been inconsistent, largely due to the turbulent period under Julen Lopetegui. The Spanish manager’s tenure at West Ham was short-lived and characterized by tactical instability, which did little to help Paquetá’s form. However, with Graham Potter now at the helm, there is renewed hope that the Brazilian can find his best level again. Potter’s style of play, which emphasizes structured buildup and technical play, could allow Paquetá to thrive if properly utilized.
What’s Next for Paquetá?
Ultimately, Paquetá’s future is still uncertain. If he can rediscover his best form under Potter and the FA charges are resolved in his favor, he could once again become one of the most in-demand midfielders in Europe. However, his next destination will likely depend on finding a club whose tactical approach suits his style.
Liverpool, with their high-intensity pressing game, might not be the ideal fit, as Carragher suggests. However, a more possession-based side—such as Manchester City or even a return to a top club in Spain or Italy—could make better use of his qualities. West Ham fans will hope that, at least for now, Potter can get the best out of him and ensure that his undeniable talent translates into consistent performances.
For now, Paquetá remains one of the Premier League’s most intriguing players—capable of breathtaking moments but still searching for the perfect system to unlock his full potential on a regular basis.